Would Society collapse into Barbarism without Religion?

GIORDANO BRUNO BURNING  by André Durand (2000) (Rome, Giordano Bruno, martyrdom, Campo de' Fiori, stake, scientist, science, astronomy)
Some Christians are under the false impression that without religion, society would collapse into utter chaos and barbarism. If we were still superstitious, illiterate, ignorant Bronze Age nomads, that MIGHT be true, but this assumption is completely false in today’s modern world.

Just look at what western society looked like before Science and Reason appeared in the Enlightenment. For more than 1,500  years, Superstition reigned supreme. Women who behaved a little oddly were deemed to be devil-possessed witches and either drowned or burned at the stake. Diseases were believed to be caused by evil spirits. People were regularly killed for thought crimes. Stop and think about that:  Under Christianity’s long rule, killing people just for what they believed was routine, accepted, moral practice. The Christian Church had absolute control and barbarism was the means of maintaining its control over the populace.

As Science and Reason have advanced and have pushed Religion to the sidelines of power, we have become a much more tolerant and advanced society. Instead of believing that evil spirits or “humors” cause disease and therefore should be removed by blood letting or exorcisms, Science has shown us that the origin and treatment of disease has absolutely nothing to do with supernatural beings, good or bad.

Protestants killing Catholics for thought crimes
 St. Margaret Clitherow is “pressed” to death.

Rather than believing that persons who suddenly fall to the ground, frothing at the mouth, trembling from head to foot, are possessed by demons, Science has shown us that they have a medical disorder.  We no longer drown and burn women who act oddly.  We simply accept that they are odd.  Diseases by the hundreds can now be treated and even cured by scientific advances in medicine, not by holding exorcisms or prayer vigils.  These advances in the human condition are due to Science, Reason, and Logic and not due to Religion or its gods.

Giovanni Battista Bugatti, executioner of the Papal States between 1796 and 1865, carried out 516 executions (Bugatti is pictured here offering snuff to a condemned prisoner). The Vatican City abolished its capital punishment statute in 1969.

Therefore, I believe that men and women who place Science and Reason as the foundation of their belief system, and collectively, the foundation of their societies, have a GREATER chance of behaving in a more egalitarian, compassionate, humanistic, and yes, moral, manner than people who believe that the Supernatural controls all aspects of life and that an ancient middle-eastern holy book, written by scientifically ignorant Bronze and Iron Age nomads, is the source of all wisdom, truth, and knowledge.

Religion served its purpose at one time. It gave us a sense of order to a universe that made no sense. Now that we understand that droughts, floods, crop failures or successes, disease, and even death are not caused by invisible gods in the sky, religion, at least fundamentalist religion, is no longer needed.

 The destruction of knowledge
The Roman Catholic Church feared knowledge and went to great
lengths to suppress learning. Libraries were destroyed and scholars
were murdered. Here, a cardinal, eager to advertise his enforcement
of the Roman Catholic Church’s decree about knowledge commissioned
this painting as proof of his adherence to the church’s doctrines..

3 thoughts on “Would Society collapse into Barbarism without Religion?

  1. Science! Reason!

    What crock. People don't change, regardless of what ideology you place on them, especially since “science” and “reason” don't really lend themselves to codes of conduct. Give me a break, Gary.


  2. All right! Let's make a temple to Reason and behead the bourgeoisie! That Enlightenment sure was great!

    Gary, you're so, so naive.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s